Henry
is a Coward – Disagree
In
the Red Badge of Courage, by Stephen Crane, the protagonist, Henry fled
from his first fight and felt guilty. He then returned to his regiment after
being hit in the head by a soldier. At the end of the book, Henry fought with
courage and strength and won the battle with his friend, Wilson. I do not agree
that Henry is a coward, because he enlisted to join the army, defeated his own
will of running away, and encouraged his regiment to stay strong when they were
about to retreat.
Henry is not a coward
because he enlisted to join the army. He was a young man and had the courage
and determination to join the army, even though his mother kept on telling him
how dangerous it is (p8, 9). He knew joining the army and fight a battle is
dangerous, but he didn’t care and wanted to help save his country. He is not
coward because he determined to enlist even though he knew it may cost his life.
Henry
is not a coward because he defeated his own will of running away on his first
battle. He was always so concerned that he would flee before the battle
(p13-48). However, Henry stayed and fought with the other veterans, instead of
running away as he expected. He felt like “he became not a man, but a member”
(p51) and “had a mad feeling against his rifle, which could only be used
against one life at a time” (p53). He was no longer afraid and fought hard and
willingly.
Henry
is not a coward because he encouraged his regiment to keep fight even though
the lieutenant already told them to retreat or they would get killed. Henry didn’t
care but kept going forward. He is a real hero because he convinced the
regiment to not give up, and eventually, they won that battle. He didn’t get
his honor of “best fight in his regiment” by lying (like before), but by his
true effort he put into the battle.
I
disagree that Henry is a coward because he determined to enlist even though he
knew it’s dangerous, defeated his own fear of running away, and fought till the
very end of his last battle for the purpose of helping his country.
No comments:
Post a Comment